The 20 Best D•A•M Local Pizza Places in Savannah, Georgia
Where to find the best local pizza places in Savannah — from legendary neighborhood institutions to stand out Neapolitan, Sicilian and creative pies
Savannah's Pizza scene is filled with a variety of flavors. The best part is that Savannah doesn't have one pizza style that dominates the city. You can find thin crust, Neapolitan, Sicilian, creative pies, neighborhood pizza and late-night slices — often within a few miles of each other.
For this list, we looked at current customer reviews along with recommendations and coverage from Eat It and Like It, Savannah Magazine, Connect Savannah and other Savannah-area food sources. We also considered local reputation, consistency and the overall dining experience.d
1. Vinnie Van Go-Go's 🏆🍕
Vinnie Van Go-Go's
Address: 151 Habersham St, Savannah, GA 31401
Phone: 912-233-6398
Google Review: 4.4/5 — 3,000+ reviews
Yelp Review: 4+ stars — thousands of reviews
Hours: Check current hours before visiting
Price: $$
Vinnie Van Go-Go's isn't simply one of Savannah's best pizza restaurants — it's one of the city's most recognizable pizza institutions. The restaurant has repeatedly dominated Savannah's pizza categories, including multiple Best of Savannah wins from local publications. Their pizza is served hot straight out of a clay pizza oven, giving it a one of a kind flavor & a Newyorker Style Pie.
The atmosphere is artsy and one of a kind. Along their falls you'll find hip artwork by Sherman Fairy and a staff that has it's own unique culture. The pizza is straightforward, yummy and built around a thin, hearty crust, rich sauce and plenty of cheese. It's exactly the kind of pizza that has earned Vinnie's a loyal following for years.
If you're looking for the quintessential Savannah pizza experience, Vinnie's belongs at the top of the list.
2. Screamin' Mimi's 🥈
Screamin' Mimi's
Address: 513 E. Oglethorpe Ave, Savannah, GA 31401
Phone: 912-236-2744
Google Review: 4.5/5 — 2,500+ reviews
Yelp Review: 4+ stars — hundreds of reviews
Hours: Sun–Thu 11 AM–10 PM; Fri–Sat 11 AM–11 PM
Price: $$
For years, Screamin' Mimi's has been Vinnie's closest competitor in Savannah's pizza rankings. It has repeatedly finished near the top of local Best Pizza competitions, and it's easy to understand why. It is "The Place" for New Jersey Style Pizza and often you'll find tourists coming from all over the states to devour it.
The restaurant makes its own dough and cooks its pies in brick ovens. The result is a classic pizza experience with a neighborhood feel, plenty of local character and is run by a family that knows their stuff.
If Vinnie's represents Savannah pizza tradition, Screamin' Mimi's is right there beside it.
Pizzeria Vittoria Napoletana
Address: 2411 De Soto Ave, Savannah, GA 31401
Phone: 912-417-3002
Google Review: Approximately 4.4/5 — 300+ reviews
Yelp Review: Highly reviewed
Hours: Check current hours before visiting
Price: $$
If you're judging pizza strictly on the quality of the pie, Pizzeria Vittoria has a legitimate argument for the number-one spot.
Eat It and Like It has repeatedly called Vittoria Savannah's best pizza, while its 2023 Foodie Awards named Vittoria Best Pizza.
The Neapolitan-style pies are carefully made, beautifully blistered and focused on quality ingredients rather than gimmicks.
This is Savannah's place for Modern artisan pizza.
Treylor Park Pizza Party
Address: 121 Martin Luther King Jr Blvd, Savannah, GA 31401
Phone: 912-232-1110
Google Review: Approximately 4.6/5 — 500+ reviews
Yelp Review: Approximately 4.2/5 — 90+ reviews
Hours: Check current hours before visiting
Price: $$
Treylor Park Pizza Party takes pizza in a more creative direction. The restaurant is part of the Treylor Park family, so you can expect combinations that go beyond traditional pepperoni and cheese.
The creativity works because the restaurant doesn't lose sight of what makes pizza good in the first place: a solid crust, flavorful toppings and a pie that people actually want to eat.
Basil's Pizza & Deli
Address: 216 Johnny Mercer Blvd, Savannah, GA 31410
Phone: 912-897-6400
Google Review: Approximately 4.3/5 — 1,000+ reviews
Yelp Review: Approximately 3.2/5 — 190+ reviews
Hours: Mon–Thu 11 AM–9:30 PM; Fri–Sat 11 AM–10:30 PM; Sun 11 AM–9 PM
Price: $$
Basil's brings something different to Savannah's pizza conversation: a neighborhood restaurant with a strong local following on Wilmington Island.
The menu goes beyond pizza, but the pies remain a major reason people return. Basil's is particularly appealing if you're looking for a family neighborhood spot rather than a destination restaurant. It even has a great place for the kids to play while the patrons can sit and watch them on a large monitor.
For Wilmington Island residents, Basil's is a local pizza staple that deserves a place on the Savannah pizza map.
6. Huc-A-Poos
Huc-A-Poos
Address: 1213 E. Hwy 80, Tybee Island, GA 31328
Phone: 912-786-5900
Google Review: Approximately 4.6/5 — 5,000+ reviews
Yelp Review: Approximately 4.0/5 — 900+ reviews
Hours: Check current hours before visiting
Price: $
Huc-A-Poos is one of those places that has become part of the personality of the community.
Located on Tybee Island, Huc-A-Poos is famous for its enormous, casual pizzas and funky atmosphere. This isn't fine dining — and that's exactly the point.
It's affordable, fun and unmistakably local.
If you're spending the day on Tybee and want a memorable pizza experience, Huc-A-Poos should be on your list.
7. Hop Atomica
Hop Atomica
Address: 620 E. 37th St, Savannah, GA 31401
Phone: 912-235-0561
Google Review: Approximately 4.7/5 — 700+ reviews
Yelp Review: Approximately 4.2/5 — 170+ reviews
Hours: Check current hours
Price: $$
Hop Atomica has built a strong reputation for combining craft beer with seriously good pizza.
The restaurant's pies fit naturally into its neighborhood brewery atmosphere, making this a great place for people who want excellent food without a formal restaurant experience.
Its strong customer ratings are a reflection of the restaurant's consistency, atmosphere and overall experience.
8. Graffito
Address: Plant Riverside District, Savannah, GA
Phone: Check current listing
Google Review: Approximately 4.4/5 — 1,000+ reviews
Yelp Review: Approximately 4/5 — 200+ reviews
Hours: Check current hours
Price: $$
Graffito has quickly established itself as an important part of Savannah's modern pizza scene.
Connect Savannah has highlighted its authentic Neapolitan approach, quality ingredients and specialized ovens.
Located in the Plant Riverside District, Graffito also has an advantage that few pizza restaurants can match: an impressive setting along the Savannah River.
Address: 4501 Montgomery St, Suite F, Savannah, GA 31405
Phone: 912-499-5665
Google Review: Approximately 4.5/5 — 400+ reviews
Yelp Review: Highly reviewed
Hours: Mon–Fri 11 AM–9 PM; Sat 12–9 PM; Sun 12–6 PM
Price: $
Kool Vibes has developed a strong following by combining New York-style pizza with a menu that isn't afraid to experiment.
One of the restaurant's most talked-about creations is its oxtail pizza, which has helped separate Kool Vibes from the city's more traditional pizzerias.
If you're looking for something outside the usual pizza lineup, Kool Vibes is worth checking out.
10. Big Bon Bodega
Address: Savannah, GA
Phone: Check current listing
Google Review: Approximately 4.6/5 — 700+ reviews
Yelp Review: 200+ reviews
Hours: Check current hours
Price: $$
Big Bon Bodega has made a name for itself with thick, square Sicilian-style pizza.
Eat It and Like It specifically calls attention to Big Bon's Savannah Square pies, and Connect Savannah has also singled out the restaurant as worthy of recognition in Savannah's pizza scene.
The square format gives Big Bon a personality all its own and makes it an especially good choice when you want something different from a traditional round pie.
11. Veratina
Address: Savannah, GA
Phone: Check current listing
Google Review: Approximately 4.5/5 — 250+ reviews
Yelp Review: Approximately 4.6/5 — 50+ reviews
Hours: Check current hours
Price: $$
Veratina brings an upscale approach to pizza and Italian-inspired food.
The restaurant has developed particularly strong customer ratings, making it one of the newer names worth knowing in Savannah's increasingly competitive pizza scene.
It's a good choice when you're looking for something a little more polished than the traditional neighborhood pizzeria.
Riverboat Pizza Company
Address: 5975 Ogeechee Rd #1200, Savannah, GA 31419
Phone: Check current listing
Google Review: Approximately 4.4/5 — 750+ reviews
Yelp Review: 700+ reviews
Hours: Check current hours
Price: $$
Riverboat Pizza Company has earned a loyal customer base and has also received recognition from local food writers.
Eat It and Like It includes Riverboat among its honorable mentions when discussing Savannah pizza.
It's the kind of neighborhood restaurant that may not get the same tourist attention as some downtown names, but local customers know where to find it.
Vincenzo's Pizzeria
Address: Savannah, GA
Phone: Check current listing
Google Review: Approximately 4.2/5 — 75+ reviews
Yelp Review: Approximately 4.0/5 — 75+ reviews
Hours: Check current hours
Price: $$
Vincenzo's is a neighborhood-style pizzeria that focuses on familiar Italian-American favorites.
It doesn't try to reinvent pizza. Instead, it delivers the kind of traditional menu that keeps local customers coming back.
For diners who prefer classic pizza over experimental toppings, Vincenzo's is a solid Savannah option.
Costanzo's Pizzeria
Address: Savannah, GA
Phone: Check current listing
Google Review: Approximately 3.9/5 — 100+ reviews
Yelp Review: 600+ reviews
Hours: Check current hours
Price: $$
Costanzo's is another local option for diners looking for traditional pizza and Italian-American comfort food.
The restaurant has a broad menu, making it useful when everyone at the table isn't necessarily in the mood for the same thing.
Allyanna's Olde Style Pizzeria
Address: Savannah, GA
Phone: Check current listing
Google Review: Approximately 4.0/5 — 500+ reviews
Yelp Review: 500+ reviews
Hours: Check current hours
Price: $$
Allyanna's focuses on an old-school pizzeria experience.
The appeal is familiar food, generous portions and a neighborhood atmosphere rather than an elaborate dining experience.
It's a good choice for anyone who likes pizza the traditional way.
Bella's Italian Cafe
Address: Savannah, GA
Phone: Check current listing
Google Review: Approximately 4.5/5 — 1,000+ reviews
Yelp Review: 1,000+ reviews
Hours: Check current hours
Price: $$
Bella's is much more than a pizza restaurant, but its Italian menu makes it a natural part of Savannah's pizza conversation.
The restaurant's strong overall reputation helped it earn Best Italian Restaurant honors from Savannah Magazine.
If you're dining with someone who wants Italian food rather than strictly pizza, Bella's gives you plenty of options.
17. Kay's Pizza
Kay's Pizza
Address: Savannah, GA
Phone: Check current listing
Google Review: Approximately 3.2/5 — 100+ reviews
Yelp Review: Approximately 3.0/5 — 100+ reviews
Hours: Check current hours
Price: $
Kay's is a longtime late-night Savannah option and has a place in the city's food culture that goes beyond traditional restaurant rankings.
Savannah Magazine has recognized Kay's in its late-night food category, making it an especially useful option when the pizza craving hits after hours.
Address: 103 Jones Ave, Tybee Island, GA 31328
Phone: 912-786-5870
Google Review: Approximately 4.5/5 — 200+ reviews
Yelp Review: Check current rating
Hours: Approximately 4–9 PM daily
Price: $
Pizza On Your Wheels is a casual Tybee Island pizza option that keeps things simple.
It's particularly convenient when you're looking for an easy pizza meal while spending time on the island.
The restaurant's current customer ratings show that it has developed a solid following among people looking for a casual local pie.
Address: Savannah, GA
Phone: Check current listing
Google Review: Check current rating
Yelp Review: Check current rating
Hours: Mon–Thu 11 AM–9 PM; Fri–Sat 11 AM–10 PM; Sun 11 AM–9 PM
Price: $$
Spanky's has been part of Savannah's restaurant scene for years, and pizza is one of the specialties that keeps it relevant.
The casual atmosphere makes it a natural choice for families, groups and visitors looking for an uncomplicated Savannah meal.
If you're already a fan of Spanky's, the pizza is worth trying alongside its other longtime menu favorites.
Address: Tybee Island, GA
Phone: Check current listing
Google Review: Approximately 3.4/5 — 800+ reviews
Yelp Review: Approximately 2.7/5 — 200+ reviews
Hours: Check current hours
Price: $
Lighthouse Pizza rounds out the list as another familiar Tybee Island pizza option.
It's a great option for visitors looking for a casual pizza meal after spending a day at the beach.
So, Which Pizza Is Actually the Best in Savannah?
That's where things get interesting.
If you want Savannah's most iconic pizza experience, Vinnie Van Go-Go's is hard to beat.
If you want classic local competition, Screamin' Mimi's is right behind it.
If you're looking for serious artisan Neapolitan pizza, Pizzeria Vittoria deserves your attention.
If you want creative pizza, Treylor Park Pizza Party is the place to explore.
If you're heading to Tybee Island, Huc-A-Poos remains one of the island's most memorable pizza experiences.
And if you want something completely different, Big Bon Bodega, Kool Vibes and Graffito are all worth putting on your list.
That's what makes Savannah's pizza scene so good.
It's not about finding one winner.
It's about having plenty of really good places to choose from.
Sources
This ranking considers current customer reviews along with local food coverage and awards from Savannah Magazine, Connect Savannah and Eat It and Like It, rather than relying on a single review platform.
Comments